| Name | Date | Location | ||
| Yake | Maggie | 1899 Oct 26> | SA | Peterborough |
| Yates | B B | 1973 - 1981 | A | Belmont and Norwood |
| Yates | Bryan | 2005 - 2010 | A | Hastings & Roseneath |
| York | James R | 2002 - 2011 | U | Hastings Roseneath |
| Yoshioka | Edward S | 1968 - 1970 | U | Coboconk |
| Youll | C T | 1991 - 1992 | A | Bridgenorth Omemee |
| Youmans | Jay S | 1853 - 1854 | WM | Percy |
| Young | Daniel | 1959 - 1970 | B | Peterborough - Murray St |
| Young | E W | 1937 - 1944 | U | Peterborough - St Andrews |
| Young | George D | 1948 - 1951 | U | Marmora |
| Young | J Mason | 1938 May 12 - 1940 | P | Lakefield |
| Young | Maxwell | 1957 Jun 27 - 1958 Oct> | SA | Haliburton |
| Young | S | 1859 - 1860 | ME | Hastings |
| Young | W A McKim | 1903 | M | Blairton |
| Young | W Harold | 1920 - 1924 | M | Peterborough - George St |
| Young | William | 1831 | ME | Cavan |
| Young | William | 1835 | WM | Cavan |
| Young | William | <1843 Jul 10 - 1845 May 3> | WM | Asphodel |
| Young | William C | 1867 Oct 20 - 1873 Apr 15 | PF | Hastings |
| Young | William R | 1893 - 1896 | M | Peterborough - George St |
| Yourkevich | Daniel O | 1985 - 1988 | U | Peterborough - Westdale |
| Yourkevich | Daniel O (student) | 1975 - 1976 | U | Buckhorn |
| Yule | George | 1902 - 1905 | P | Springville and Bethany |
| Zimmerman | John | 1984 Dec - 1988 Apr | L | Peterborough - Christ |
| Zufelt | V E R | 1937 - 1940 | U | Peterborough - Knox |
| Zwicker | Robert & Garda | 1984 Jun - 1988 Sep> | SA | Peterborough |