| Name | Date | Location | ||
| Salmon | I Bruce | <1995 Sep - 1997 Feb> | PA | Curve Lake |
| Salmon | I Bruce | <1998 Jan - 2000 Apr> | PA | Curve Lake |
| Sanderson | E A | 1895 - 1898 | M | Blairton |
| Sanderson | John | 1836 - 1837 | MX | Peterborough |
| Sanderson | John | 1840 | WM | Peterborough |
| Sanderson | John | <1847 Oct 2 - 1848 Aug 12> | WM | Norwood |
| Sanderson | John | 1854 | WM | Mud Lake Indian |
| Sanderson | John | 1868 - 1869 | WM | Warsaw |
| Sanderson | Joseph E | 1880 - 1882 | MC | Norwood |
| Sanderson | William | <1851 Aug 9 - 1852 May 15> | WM | Norwood |
| Sanderson | William | 1857 | WM | Percy |
| Sanderson | William | 1858 | WM | Seymour |
| Sanson | David (lay supply) | 1961 - 1963 | U | Warsaw |
| Saroea-Alexander | E A | 1990 - 1991 | U | Apsley Cardiff Paudash |
| Sauren | R | 1915 Mar 5 - 1916 May | SA | Norland |
| Savage | David | 1859 - 1860 | MX | Cavan |
| Sawers | Frederick John | 1909 Nov - 1911 May | A | Lakefield - St John |
| Sawers | Frederick John | 1911 May - 1915 Feb 28 | A | Peterborough - St Luke |
| Saynor | John K (asst) | 1996 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Saynor | John K(asst) | 1989 - 1990 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Scanlon | P | 1990 - 1993 | A | Peterborough - St Alban |
| Schofield | William H | 1865 | WM | Coboconk |
| Schofield | William H | 1868 - 1869 | WM | Lakefield, etc |
| Schroeder | Mike | 1988 Apr - date | L | Peterborough - Christ |
| Schwab | James | 1942 May 14 - 1943 Jan> | SA | Haliburton |
| Scorgie | James L | 1956 - 1958 | BF | Bobcaygeon |
| Scott | Douglas | 1998 - 2002 | P | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Scott | Freeman J | 1904 Nov - 1906 Dec | B | Peterborough - Murray St |
| Scott | Hattie M | 1890 Jun 1> | SA | Kinmount |
| Scott | James | 1986 - 1995 | RC | Peterborough - St John |
| Scott | Munroe | 2010 - 2013 | A | Lakefield |
| Scott | N E | 1876 - 1877 | ME | Blairton |
| Scott | R L | 1979 - 1981 | A | Apsley |
| Scott | R L (asst) | 1977 - 1978 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Scott | W J | <1982 - 1985> | RC | Peterborough - St Anne |
| Scott | William | 1857 - 1858 | WM | Peterborough |
| Scott | William L | 1874 - 1875 | MC | Lakefield |
| Scott | William L | 1858 | WM | Bridgenorth |
| Scott | William L | 1860 | WM | Percy |
| Scott | William L | 1863 - 1865 | WM | Keene |
| Scott | William L | 1873 | WM | Lakefield, etc |
| Scott-Beccleuch | Ian L | 1959 - 1961 | A | Pbo - St Barnabas Mission |
| Scott-Beccleuch | Ian L | 1961 - 1964 | A | Peterborough - St Barnabas |
| Scott-Beccleuch | Ian L (asst) | 1957 - 1958 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Scuse | Harvey James | 1951 - 1960 | A | Peterborough - St George |
| Seaborn | F J | 1967 May 6 | O | Latter Day Saints |
| Seaboyer | Robert L | 1967 | PA | Havelock |
| Seaboyer | Stephen R | 2002 Jan - date | PA | Ennismore - Causeway |
| Seabrooke | Peter | <1982 - 1988> | RC | Cobourg |
| Seabrooke | Peter | <1990 - 1997 | RC | Peterborough - St Alphonsus |
| Searight | Thomas | post 1836 | O | Norwood Congregational |
| Seccombe | William B | 1901 - 1904 | M | Keene |
| Seccombe | William Bray | 1888 | M | Blairton |
| Sellery | W | 1879 | ME | Kinmount |
| Selvaraj | Peter | 2003 | RC | Norwood |
| Semple | James A | 1944 - 1949 | U | Peterborough - George St |
| Sexsmith | W V | 1884 | M | Hiawatha |
| Seymour | Edgar O | 1920 - 1925 | M | Havelock |
| Seymour | Edgar O | 1925 | U | Havelock |
| Seymour | Howard P L | 1934 - 1936 | U | Springville |
| Shank | Hervey R | 1979 - 1981 | PA | Bridgenorth |
| Shannon | John | 1951 | PA | Norwood |
| Shannon | John | <1859 Aug 6 - 1861 May 18> | WM | Norwood |
| Sharp | C Robin | 1983 - 1987 | U | Peterborough - George St |
| Sharp | Douglas | 1951 Sep 27 - 1951 Oct> | SA | Peterborough |
| Sharpe | Lucas M | 1942 Oct 2 - 1948 May 11 | P | Lakefield |
| Sharpe | W L (Tim) (asst) | 2000 | A | Minden |
| Shatto | M | 1969 | U | Apsley Paudash |
| Shaver | Augustus W | 1900 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Shaw | Calvin | 1871 - 1873 | MX | Cavan |
| Shaw | H | 1903 - 1904 | B | Indian River |
| Shaw | John | 1881 - 1883 | MC | Peterborough - George St |
| Shearer | G | 1900 Nov | P | Harvey |
| Shearman | David K | 1987 - 1992 | U | Lakefield |
| Shearman | Janet Wight | 1988 - 1993 | U | Buckhorn |
| Shepherd | Edmund | 1831 | ME | Smith's Creek |
| Shepherd | H S | 1954 Sep 1 - 1956 | A | Kinmount Mission |
| Sheridan | early | WM | Warsaw | |
| Sheridan | William | 1865 - 1867 | WM | Lakefield, etc |
| Sheridan | William | 1868 - 1869 | WM | Bobcaygeon |
| Shier | J W | 1896 - 1898 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Shilton | John | 1837 | MX | Peterborough |
| Shilton | John | 1850 | MX | Cavan |
| Shorey | Sidney J | 1897 Jun 28 - 1899 | M | Peterborough - George St |
| Shorey | Sidney James | 1887 - 1890 | M | Peterborough - Charlotte St |
| Shorrocks | Ann D | 1989 - 1993 | A | Stony Lake |
| Short | William | 1860 - 1862 | WM | Seymour |
| Short | William | 1866 - 1868 | WM | Hastings |
| Shorten | A Lloyd | 1953 - 1958 | U | Peterborough - St James |
| Sigston | Earl | 1946 - 1949 | A | Kinmount Mission |
| Simm | Glen Arthur | 1974 - 1978 | A | Apsley |
| Simmons | P (asst) | 1998 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Simms | Ernest R | 1900 Jul 26 - Oct | SA | Peterborough |
| Simpson | Creola M (supply) | 1992 | U | Apsley Cardiff Paudash |
| Simpson | J R (student) | 1930 May | B | Indian River |
| Simpson | John H | 1847 - 1848 | MX | Cavan |
| Simpson | Merton O | 1969 - 1971 | PA | Bobcaygeon - Bethel |
| Sims | Roland E | 1973 - 1982 | A | Bridgenorth Omemee |
| Sinclair | M R | 1962 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Sing | Samuel | 1894 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Sissmore | David | 1978 - 1982 | A | Stony Lake |
| Siverns | L Edward | 1966 - 1969 May 15 | P | Warkworth Hastings |
| Skelding | D W | 1940 - 1942 | FM | Cordova, Victoria, Methuen |
| Skene | James | 1910 - 1921 | P | Havelock - Knox |
| Slater | James C | 1847 | WM | McKees |
| Slater | James C | 1847 | WM | Peterborough |
| Slater | James C | <1852 Jul 31 - 1853 | WM | Norwood |
| Slater | John | 1895 Oct 3> | SA | Kinmount |
| Slater | Wm | 1826 - 1827 | ME | Smith's Creek |
| Slimon | J H | 1914 Nov 1 - 1917 Jun 17 | B | Lakefield |
| Slingerland | Leonard | 1906 | FM | Trent Bridge, Victoria, Cordova |
| Sloan | James W | 1869 | WM | Halls Bridge |
| Sloan | James W | 1870 | WM | Warsaw |
| Sloan | John G (supply) | 1987 - 1988 | U | Peterborough - Knox |
| Sloan | John G | 2009 | U | Bailieboro - Springville |
| Sloane | James W | 1870 | WM | Mud Lake Indian |
| Slote | 1887 May 20 - Nov | SA | Bobcaygeon | |
| Slote | 1890 Oct | SA | Kinmount | |
| Smart | James D | 1942 Jan 2 - 1944 Aug 31 | p | Peterborough - St Paul |
| Smart | Walter S | 1904 | M | Blairton |
| Smeaton | Ronald C | 1972 - 1980 | U | Peterborough - Knox |
| Smiley | John | 1878 - 1880 | MC | Bobcaygeon |
| Smith | E Gilmour (ret supply) | 1968 | U | Peterborough - Grace |
| Smith | Andrew A | <1850Aug 3 - 1851 May 3> | WM | Norwood |
| Smith | Angela (lay) | 2001 - 2002 | B | Peterborough - Murray St |
| Smith | Arthur | 1922 Aug 24 - 1925 Dec> | SA | Peterborough |
| Smith | Bertha | 1886 Jan 21 - 1886 Aug | SA | Peterborough |
| Smith | Carl Shuter (asst) | 1896 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Smith | D Mansell (ret supply) | 1967 | U | Apsley |
| Smith | E G | 1960 Oct 28 - 1964 Jan 1 | P | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Smith | E Gilmour | 1959 - 1960 | U | Peterborough - George St |
| Smith | E Gilmour | 1963 - 1967 | U | Peterborough - George St |
| Smith | Ernest C | 1954 - 1959 | B | Gilmour Memorial |
| Smith | G Moore W (asst) | 1983 - 1994 | A | Lakefield - St John |
| Smith | Gilbert D | 1953 Jun 23 - 1961 Mar 20 | P | Peterborough - St Giles |
| Smith | Isaac B | 1815 | ME | Smith's Creek |
| Smith | J B | 1862 | ME | Norwood |
| Smith | J W | 1888 Mar 1 - Jul | SA | Bobcaygeon |
| Smith | James W | 1998 - 2002 | B | Peterborough - Murray St |
| Smith | May | 1919 Mar 6> | SA | Peterborough 2 |
| Smith | Percival Clementi (asst) | 1878 - 1879 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Smith | Philander | 1820 | ME | Smith's Creek |
| Smith | Steven | 2006 - 2013 | A | Peterborough - St Luke |
| Smith | W G | 1902 Oct 29 - 1917 | P | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Smithett | William Thomas | 1869 - 1871 | A | Norwood, Hastings, etc |
| Smullen | Damian | 2002 - date | RC | Lakefield |
| Smythe | Gordon C | 1966 - 1970 | U | Peterborough - St Andrews |
| Smythe | W J H | 1912 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Snelgrove | E D | 1941 - 1946 | U | Warsaw |
| Snelgrove | E D (probationer) 1926 | 1926 | U | Halls Bridge |
| Snelgrove | E D (student) | 1932 | U | Kinmount |
| Snell | Isaac | 1915 - 1918 | M | Hastings |
| Snell | L Douglas | 1968 - 1969 | U | Peterborough - George St |
| Snider | Eric (lay supply) | 1955 | U | Kinmount |
| Snider | Kenneth J | 1968 - 1975 | FM | Peterborough |
| Snider | Solomon | 1839 | WM | Peterborough |
| Snowden | Thomas | 1891 - 1893 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Snyder | Austin F | 2001 | U | Hastings Roseneath |
| Snyder | E | 1914 - 1916 | FM | Peterborough |
| Snyder | Sperry | 1902 | FM | Beaver Creek and Rockdale |
| Softley | Henry | 1886 | A | Otonabee Twp - St Mark |
| Somerville | J F | 1894 Oct - 1901 | P | Norwood - St Andrews |
| South | Edward | 1916 Sep 14 - 1917 Apr> | SA | Norland |
| Soward | Edward | 1877 - 1879 | A | Norwood, Westwood, etc |
| Soward | Edward | 1883 - 1905 | A | Galway |
| Sparrow | P L | 1864 | ME | Norwood |
| Spence | C A G (ret) | 1943 Mar - 1946 May | A | Stony Lake |
| Spence | Claude Augustus Green | 1919 - 1937 | A | Apsley |
| Spence | Claude Augustus Green (asst) | 1918 | A | Peterborough South |
| Spence | H S | 1896 | M | Apsley |
| Spencely | John B | 1959 - 1965 | U | Peterborough - St James |
| Spencer | 1889 Jun 13 - Jul> | SA | Norwood | |
| Spencer | Cecil | 1917 Aug - 1918 Oct | A | Lakefield - St John |
| Spencer | Clarence Reginald | 1908 - 1909 | A | South Burleigh & Buckhorn |
| Spencer | Clarence Reginald | 1908 Apr - 1910 Jan 31 | A | Stony Lake |
| Spencer | Clarence Reginald (ret) | 1948 - 1950 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Spencer | Ralph E | 1925 - 1926 | M | Wesley |
| Spencer | Ralph E(probationer) | 1925 | U | Halls Bridge |
| Spencer | W | 1926 Oct - 1927 Nov | B | Lakefield |
| Spring | F C | 1957 - 1961 | PA | Bobcaygeon - Glad Tidings |
| Sproule | A H (student) | 1925 Dec - 1927 Oct | B | Bobcaygeon |
| St Pierre | Mark J (lay) | 1993 - 2002 | B | Selwyn |
| Stacey | 1886 Mar - 1886 Apr | SA | Lakefield | |
| Stanley | Charles | 1968 Jun 27 - 1969 Jan> | SA | Byersville |
| Stanley | Thomas Henry | 1921 - 1927 | A | Belmont |
| Stanley | William | 1964 Jun 25 - 1964 Nov> | SA | Fenelon Falls |
| Staples | Robert J F | 1910 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Stark | Murray | 1985 - 2000 | O | Pbo Christian Fellowship |
| Starr | John Edward | 1880 - 1881 | MC | Peterborough - George St |
| Starratt | Paul | 1979 | PA | Peterborough - Full Gospel |
| Starratt | Paul V | 1981 - 1988 | PA | Peterborough - Northview |
| Steedman | L S | 1904 Oct 28 - 1907 Dec 1 | B | Indian River |
| Steele | John R | 1892 Feb - Jun | SA | Peterborough |
| Steele | Thomas P | 1884 - 1885 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Steele | Thomas P | 1902 - 1904 | M | Hastings |
| Steele | Thomas P | 1883 - 1885 | MC | Bobcaygeon |
| Steenburg | G | 1910 | FM | Trent Bridge, Victoria, Cordova |
| Stephenson | Elsie (asst) | 1997 - 2003 | A | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Stephenson | John (asst) | 2002 - 2004 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Stephenson | William E | 1979 - 1985 | U | Hastings Roseneath |
| Sterling | J A G | 1906 | P | Harvey |
| Sternall | R E | 1945 | PA | Havelock |
| Stevens | H | 1855 - 1856 | BC | Dummer - English Line |
| Stevens | Wm H | 1891 Feb 1 - 1894 Jan 4 | B | Norwood |
| Stevenson | B E | 1917 | FM | Peterborough |
| Stevenson | Edward Vicars | 1898 - 1899 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Stevenson | Edward Vicars (asst) | 1896 - 1897 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Stevenson | James | 1957 - 1966 | PA | Peterborough - Dublin St |
| Stevenson | Robert (missionary) | 1880 Nov - 1882 | P | Kinmount |
| Stevenson | W W | 1953 - 1963 | PA | Havelock |
| Steves | W C | nd | B | Lakefield |
| Stewart | F J | 1970 - 1973 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Stewart | Ken R | 1936 - 1938 | U | Wesley |
| Stewart | Kenneth (lay supply) | 1947 - 1963 | U | Wesley |
| Stibbard | Edith | 1954 Jul 1 - 1955 Sep> | SA | Campbellford |
| Stillman | R Forbes | <1925 Jul 27 - 1932 Jun 27> | M | Norwood |
| Stillman | R Forbes | <1925 Jul 27 - 1932 Jun 27> | U | Norwood |
| Stinson | Dewey M | 1922 | M | South Dummer |
| Stinson | Joseph H | 1864 | WM | Bobcaygeon |
| Stinson | Joseph H | 1865 | WM | Lakefield, etc |
| Stinson | Joseph H | 1866 - 1867 | WM | Warsaw |
| Stirling | J A | 1907 - 1910 Mar 21 | P | Havelock - Knox |
| Stobo | E J | 1880 Sep - 1882 Jan | B | Peterborough - Aylmer St |
| Stock | Thomas | 1869 - 1871 | B | Peterborough - Aylmer St |
| Stock | Thomas | 1869 - 1871 | B | Smith |
| Stocks | William | 1937 - 1940 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Stockton | F | 1890 Mar - 1890 Jun | SA | Lakefield |
| Stockton | Frank | 1889 Jun 13> | SA | Kinmount |
| Stockton | James R | 1985 | U | Peterborough - Grace |
| Stockton | James R | 1986 - 1989 | U | Peterborough - St Andrews |
| Stockton | Jessie L | 1984 - 1988 | U | Peterborough - George St |
| Stoute | Douglas A (asst) | 1983 | A | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Straker | E Leonard | 1971 - 1984 | A | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Stratton | Donald B | 1971 - 1977 | B | Peterborough - Murray St |
| Street | George Charles | 1839 Jul 1 - | A | Newcastle Travelling |
| Stringer | James Henry | 1920 Jun - 1920 Oct | A | Stony Lake |
| Stroh | Donald | 1976 May - 1980 Jul | L | Peterborough - Christ |
| Strutt | Donald H | 1969 - 1971 | PA | Curve Lake |
| Stubley | R J | 1957 - 1960 | A | Belmont and Norwood |
| Stuckless | Elvin B | <1993 Nov - 1995 Feb> | PA | Ennismore - Causeway |
| Sumbler | Beverly E | 2008 - 2011 | U | Warsaw |
| Sunday | John | 1836 - 1850 | WM | Rice Lake Indian |
| Sutcliffe | Joseph H | 1927 Jul - 1946 Jan | B | Peterborough - Murray St |
| Sutherland | D | 1856 | WM | Percy |
| Sutherland | Harold | 1960 Oct 16 - 1961 Oct 29 | O | Latter Day Saints |
| Sutherland | Harold I | 1979 | O | Latter Day Saints |
| Sutherland | John A | 1931 - 1933 | P | Keene Westwood |
| Sutherst | F C | 1988 - 1996 | A | Otonabee - St Mark |
| Sutton | B A | 1931 - 1933 | FM | Peterborough |
| Sutton | William | 1870 - 1872 | WM | Coboconk |
| Swanton | George | 1869 | MX | Cavan |
| Swaren | Milton A | 1965 - 1969 | B | Gilmour Memorial |
| Swift | Barry F | 1987 - 1993 Sep> | PA | Ennismore - Causeway |
| Symonds | Herbert | 1892 May 15 - 1901 May 25 | A | Ashburnham - St Luke |