| Name | Date | Location | ||
| Pace | William K | 1962 - 1964 | U | Peterborough - Grace |
| Pady | W J | 1894 - 1896 Apr | B | Peterborough - Park St |
| Page | Brian & Sharon | 1983 Jan - 1984 Dec> | SA | Peterborough South |
| Palakal | T | <1985> | RC | Kinmount |
| Palframan | W L | 1890 Oct 5 - 1892 Jul 3 | B | Lakefield |
| Palframan | W S | 1891 | B | Douro |
| Papi | R | <1988> | RC | Downyville |
| Parker | B | 1992 | A | Kinmount Mission |
| Parker | Brian D | 1993 - 1998 | A | Minden |
| Parker | Caleb | 1888 | M | Kinmount |
| Parker | Caleb | <1903 Nov 14 - 1905 Jun 28> | M | Norwood |
| Parker | Peter Clifton | 1887 Nov - 1890 Dec | B | Peterborough - Murray St |
| Parker | Richard A | 1999 - 2000 | U | Coboconk |
| Parkin | Garry D | <1993 Nov | PA | Ennismore - Causeway |
| Parks | F Wayne | 1968 | PA | Bobcaygeon - Bethel |
| Parlee | Fred H | 1950 - 1952 Mar 2 | PA | Peterborough - Full Gospel |
| Parlee | Fred H | 1952 Mar 2 - 1957 | PA | Peterborough - Dublin St |
| Parr | Maxwell G | 1935 - 1939 | U | Peterborough - George St |
| Parsons | Alice | 1892 Jan 28 - Sep> | SA | Kinmount |
| Partridge | Allan Manley | 1946 - 1948 | U | Peterborough - Mark St |
| Paterson | James Douglas Jr (asst) | 1939 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Paterson | James Douglas Sr | 1924 - 1940 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Patrick | Frank | 1987 - date | PA | Peterborough - Calvary |
| Patstone | A J (asst) | 1962 - 1977 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Patstone | A J(retired) | 1951 Sep - 1961 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Patterson | C W | <1869 Nov 21 - 1873 Jul 30> | A | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Patterson | J N | 1964 - 1967 | FM | Peterborough |
| Patterson | John | 1875 | P | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Patterson | John Henry (Jack) | 1971 - 1979 | U | Lakefield |
| Patterson | Marwood (lay) | 1951 | A | Peterborough |
| Patterson | Marwood F | 1954 Jan - 1959 Feb | A | Stony Lake |
| Patterson | Neil David | 1953 - 1960 | U | Peterborough - Mark St |
| Patterson | Robert Brunker | 1916 - 1918 | A | Belmont |
| Patterson | Susan E | 2004 - 2008 | U | Norwood Westwood |
| Patterson | T W | 1872 - 1873 | A | Hastings and Alnwick |
| Patterson | William & Mrs | 1977 Jun - 1980 Dec> | SA | Peterborough South |
| Patterson-Smyth | J | 1954 Oct 1 - 1956 | A | Belmont and Norwood |
| Patton | George (retired supply) | 1949 Jul 1 - 1951 | U | Kinmount |
| Pattyson | William M | 1882 | MC | Coboconk |
| Pattyson | William M | <1869 Jul 31 - 1872 May 4> | WM | Norwood |
| Pattyson | William M (died) | 1890 | M | Halls Bridge |
| Paul | James T | 1872 Feb 28 - 1875 Mar | PK | Dummer |
| Payton | R G | 1979 | O | Peterborough Seventh Day |
| Peacock | Ronald M | 1969 - 1979 | PA | Havelock |
| Peacock | William K | 1982 - 1985 | U | Peterborough - Knox |
| Peacock | William K | 1987 - 2011 | U | Fairview |
| Peake | J R | 1894 - 1895 | M | South Dummer |
| Pearce | 1980 | O | Peterborough Seventh Day | |
| Pearo | Everett | 1933 Jun 29 - 1935 Jan> | SA | Fenelon Falls |
| Pearson | Edwin A | 1907 - 1909 | M | Peterborough - George St |
| Pearson | John | <1990 - 1993 | RC | Lakefield |
| Pearson | John T | <1980 - 1988> | RC | Peterborough - St Peter |
| Pearson | Marmaduke L | 1888 - 1889 | M | Peterborough - George St |
| Peasgood | David H E | 1995 - 2000 | A | Belmont and Norwood |
| Peasgood | David H E | 2009 - 2013 | A | Apsley |
| Peasgood | H E | 1975 - 1977 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Peasgood | Henry Eric | 1951 - 1953 Sep 15 | A | Belmont and Norwood |
| Peasgood | Henry Eric | 1953 Sep 16 - 1958 | A | Peterborough |
| Peasgood | Henry Eric | 1953 Sep 16 - 1958 | A | Peterborough - St Alban |
| Peat | Archie | 1969 Jun 26 - 1969 Nov> | SA | Peterborough |
| Peck | William | 1849 | MX | Cavan |
| Peckover | Horace | 1906 - 1908 | P | Lakevale |
| Pedlar | Burton | 1933 Jun 29 - 1935 Jan> | SA | Haliburton |
| Peer | William | 1888 - 1891 Oct 10 | B | Norwood |
| Peer | Wm | 1896 Oct 1 - 1899 | B | Norwood |
| Peer | Wm | 1899 | B | Havelock |
| Peever | Richard G | 1913 - 1916 | M | Peterborough - George St |
| Pelletier | Herman Enos | 1931 - 1938 | A | Kinmount Mission |
| Pellman | Carston | 1980 - 1989 | B | Gilmour Memorial |
| Perdue | V | 1977 - 1980> | RC | Campbellford |
| Perdue | V G | 1981 - 1983 | RC | Peterborough - St John |
| Perdue | Vernon | 1967 Sep 29 - 1969 May | RC | Lakefield |
| Perdue | Vernon G | 1974 - 1976 | RC | Otonabee |
| Perrie | David K | 1936 Dec 10 - 1938 | P | Hastings Havelock |
| Perrie | David K | 1938 - 1942 Dec 29 | P | Hastings Havelock Norwood |
| Perrin | Daniel A | 1863 - 1864 | WM | Hastings |
| Perry | Elias | 1808 | ME | Smith's Creek |
| Perry | N F | 1916 | FM | Methuen and Oak Lake |
| Perry | N F | 1952 - 1953 | FM | Cordova, Victoria, Havelock |
| Perry | Robert | 1807 | ME | Smith's Creek |
| Pessah | S (Church Army) | 1987 | A | Kinmount Mission |
| Peters | John E | 1986 Sep - 2001 | U | Bailieboro Springville |
| Peters | John Ewart | 1970 - 1975 | U | Marmora |
| Peters | N D | 1861 | ME | Hastings |
| Peters-Derry | W Paul | 1994 - 2002 | U | Norwood Westwood |
| Peterson | Andrew L | <1856 Aug 9 - 1857 May 9> | WM | Norwood |
| Peterson | Andrew L | 1857 | WM | Lindsay |
| Peterson | Andrew L | 1858 - 1859 | WM | Percy |
| Pfeifer | John F | 1965 Oct - 1967 May 6 | O | Latter Day Saints |
| Phelan | C J | 1902 - 1911 Sep | RC | Lakefield |
| Phelan | C J | 1902 - 1911 Sep | RC | Youngs Point - St Mary |
| Phelan | Charles J | 1914 - 1921 | RC | Peterborough - St Peter |
| Phelan | Charles J | 1921 - 1934 Dec 13 | RC | Campbellford |
| Phelps | Arthur L | 1908 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Phelps | Leonard | 1914 | M | Peterborough - Mark St |
| Phelps | Richard | <1845 Jul 26 - 1847 May 15> | WM | Norwood |
| Phillips | George Barnard | 1976 - 1981 | U | Havelock |
| Phillips | J R | 1859 | ME | Hastings |
| Phillips | L G | 1969 - 1970 | A | Bridgenorth - Christ Church |
| Phillips | Samuel B | 1891 - 1893 | M | Hastings |
| Philp | Joseph | 1870 | MX | Cavan |
| Philp | Samuel C | <1866 Aug 18 - 1869 May 15> | WM | Norwood |
| Pickering | Ralph | 1966 - 1967 | U | Bridgenorth |
| Pickford | E W(asst) | 1894 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Pickford | E W | 1893 | A | Belmont |
| Pickford | E W | 1904 - 1912 | A | Norwood, Westwood, etc |
| Pierce | Frank | 1959 Jul 2 - 1961 Sep> | SA | Fenelon Falls |
| Piercy | William P (lay supply) | 1955 - 1956 | U | Apsley |
| Pink | 1887 Sep 29 - Oct | SA | Hastings | |
| Pinkerton | E O (student) | 1925 May - 1926 | B | Indian River |
| Piper | Allan | 1979 - 1985 | BF | Bobcaygeon |
| Pippen | William Austen | 1922 - 1927 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Pippen | William Austen (asst) | 1911 | A | Apsley |
| Pitcher | Joel T | 1864 - 1865 | MX | Cavan |
| Pitts | Frederick John Hewlett | 1945 - 1947 | A | Belmont and Norwood |
| Plant | Ruth | 1919 Oct 16> | SA | Peterborough 2 |
| Playter | George F | <1851 Aug 9 - 1852 May 15> | WM | Norwood |
| Podelino | Asisclo | 1996 - 2002 | RC | Peterborough - St Anne |
| Podelino | Asisclo | 2003 | RC | Peterborough - Imm Concep |
| Poelman | Jim | 1989 - 1993 | CR | Peterborough - Cephas |
| Pogue | Robert | 1907 Dec 5 - 1925 | P | Peterborough - St Paul |
| Pollock | Isaac Garroway | 1952 Jul 12 - 1956 | U | Peterborough - Grace |
| Pollock | Thomas | 1941 Jun 19 - 1942 Oct | SA | Haliburton |
| Pomeroy | W M | 1879 | ME | Blairton |
| Poole | George | 1837 - 1838 | WM | Peterborough |
| Poole | Maurice Philip | 1951 - 1964 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Poole | Vena | 1974 Jun 27 - 1974 Sep> | SA | Byersville |
| Poole | William H | 1854 - 1856 | WM | Peterborough |
| Pople | William G | 1886 Aug 12 - 1886 Oct | SA | Peterborough |
| Porter | George A | 1952 Nov 23 - 1956 | O | Latter Day Saints |
| Porter | Gordon Walsh | 1934 | U | Apsley |
| Porter | Leo & Shirley | 1989 Jun - 1992 Sep> | SA | Peterborough |
| Porter | Thomas G | 1876 | A | Hastings and Alnwick |
| Porzuczek | Ted | 1995 - 2000 | RC | Otonabee |
| Potter | 1909 Jan> | SA | Kinmount | |
| Potter | Edward (licensed) | 1978 - 1992 | B | Norwood |
| Potter | Edward (student) | 1971 - 1977 | B | Selwyn |
| Potter | J W | 1925 - 1927 | FM | Cordova, Victoria, Havelock |
| Potter | James G | 1896 Aug 27 - 1910 | P | Peterborough - St Andrew |
| Potter | Joseph | 1908 Jul 16 - Oct> | SA | Kinmount |
| Potter | Richard | 1872 - 1874 | MC | Campbellford |
| Potter | Richard | 1872 - 1874 | WM | Campbellford |
| Potts | Alexander | <1847 Oct 2 - 1848 | WM | Norwood |
| Potts | George H | 1896 | M | Harvey |
| Power | Edward K | 2006 | U | Peterborough - Knox |
| Power | Edward K | 2008 - 2009 | U | Havelock Trent |
| Power | John | 1888 - 1890 | M | Warsaw |
| Power | John | 1876 | MC | Chandos |
| Power | Melvin G | <1995 May - 2001 Feb> | PA | Ennismore - Causeway |
| Praamsma | M Elizabeth | 1992 - 1994 | U | Bobcaygeon Dunsford Prov. |
| Preston | Alfred J | 1935 Jan 3 - 1937 | P | Keene Westwood |
| Preston | W C Clarke | 1862 - 1863 | A | Rice Lake |
| Price | James | 1912 - 1919 | A | Peterborough South |
| Priest | H C | nd | B | Lakefield |
| Pince | Richard H | 2009 - 2011 | U | Peterborough- St Matthews Donwood |
| Prior | F F | 1907 | FM | Trent Br, Victoria, Cordova |
| Prosser | M George | 1981 | PA | Bobcaygeon - Bethel |
| Ptolemy-Stam | Karen E | 2002 - 2010 | U | Peterborough - George St |
| Puffer | Isaac W | 1884 - 1886 | M | Blairton |
| Pugsley | Ernest Edgar | <1942 Sep 11 - 1951 Jun 30> | U | Norwood |
| Purdon | Kenneth G (retired) | 2002 | U | Bailieboro Springville |
| Purser | John Arnold | 1968 - 1977 | A | Lakefield - St John |
| Purser | John Arnold (asst) | 1951 - 1952 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Purves | T B (asst) | 1956 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Pyne | Eugene | 1967 Jun 29 - 1969 Jan> | SA | Campbellford |
| Quaife | Charles | 1904 Jan 14 - 1905 Feb | SA | Kinmount |
| Quance | William | 1873 Jun - > | BC | Ashburnham |
| Quarrington | Walter | 1903 | B | Lakefield |
| Queen | Alex | 1980 - 1985 | FM | Cordova |
| Quibell | George | 1997 - 2000 | A | Stony Lake |
| Quibell | George | 1998 - 2001 | A | Apsley |
| Quirk | John | 1862 Feb - 1895 Jun 7 | RC | Hastings |