| Name | Date | Location | ||
| Ingleby | Ralph | 1953 Aug 8> | SA | Byersville |
| Ingram | Sabrina | 2010 - 2011 | P | Peterborough - St Stephen |
| Ingram | Terry D | 2011 - | P | Lakefield Lakehurst Warsaw |
| Innis | Bryce | 1896 - 1901 | P | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Ireland | J F | 1921 | M | Wesley |
| Irwin | A D (lay) | 1930 | U | Halls Bridge |
| Irwin | A Mansell | <1914 Jul 23 - 1919 Aug 4> | M | Norwood |
| Isaac | Pagie | 1996 - 1998 | O | Peterborough Seventh Day |
| Isherwood | Stanley T J (temp) | 1994 | A | Peterborough - St Alban |
| Ivison | James A | 1854 | WM | Mud Lake Indian |