| Name | Date | Location | ||
| Falle | Ernest | 1931 Jun 25 - 1932 Aug> | SA | Peterborough |
| Fallis | R J | 1887 | M | Blairton |
| Farncomb | Frederick Edward (asst) | 1886 | A | Lakefield - St John |
| Farncomb | John | 1882 Jul - 1889 Apr | A | Lakefield - St John |
| Farncomb | William | <1883 Jul 27 - 1890 Oct 21> | A | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Farney | Clarence Moverley | 1907 Jun - 1908 Jun | A | South Burleigh & Buckhorn |
| Farr | W T (student) | 1911 Oct - 1913 | B | Bobcaygeon |
| Farrall | John | 1853 - 1856 | RC | Peterborough - St Peter |
| Farrar | Michael Andrews | 1863 - 1866 | A | Norwood, Hastings, etc |
| Farrar | Michael Andrews | 1871 Sep - 1872 | A | Norwood, Hastings, etc |
| Farrar | Michael Andrews | 1872 - 1876 | A | Norwood, Hastings, etc |
| Farrell | James | 1968 - 1974 | RC | Peterborough - St Alphonsus |
| Farrelly | Daniel | 1856 Aug - 1858 Jun 1 | RC | Peterborough - St Peter |
| Farrelly | James | 1852 - 1857 | RC | Hastings |
| Fawcett | John | <1854 Aug 12 - 1855 May 19> | WM | Norwood |
| Feairs | James F | 1990 - 1996 | U | Peterborough - St Andrews |
| Feairs | James F | 1997 - 2001 | U | Pbo - St Matthews Donwood |
| Fellinger | Barry M | 1985 - 1986 | PA | Bobcaygeon - Bethel |
| Fellion | William | 1998 - date | RC | Kinmount |
| Ferguson | Clarence H | 1925 - 1926 | M | Cordova and Belmont |
| Ferguson | Clarence H (prob) | 1925 | U | Cordova Mines |
| Ferguson | Dan | ukn | O | Latter Day Saints |
| Ferguson | John Stewart | 1933 - 1939 | U | Keene |
| Ferguson | John Stewart | 1954 - 1958 | U | Peterborough - George St |
| Ferguson | John Stewart | 1955 | U | Peterborough - Trinity |
| Ferguson | S | 1884 | M | Kinmount |
| Ferguson | Samuel | 1888 - 1889 | M | Halls Bridge |
| Ferguson | Samuel | 1891 - 1892 | M | Coe Hill |
| Ferguson | Samuel G | 1893 | M | Blairton |
| Ferguson | Wayne W | 1961 Oct 29 - 1965 Oct | O | Latter Day Saints |
| Ferguson | Wayne W | 1980 - 1981 | O | Latter Day Saints |
| Ferns | Edgar | 1940 Nov - 1942 | B | Norwood |
| Ferris | Clarke | 1936 Nov 26> | SA | Haliburton |
| Fife | F J | 1946 May - 1952 Jun | A | Stony Lake |
| Fife | John R | 1952 Jun - 1952 Sep | A | Stony Lake |
| Filer | William Alfred | 1941 - 1947 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Fillier | Bobby W | 2004 - 2007 | U | Warsaw |
| Fillier | Bobby W | 2008 | U | Peterborough - Northminster |
| Findlay | <1893 Feb - Apr | SA | Norwood | |
| Fine | A | 1926 Jan> | O | Peterborough - Beth Israel |
| Finn | John T | 1941 Aug 29 - 1948 Jan 25 | RC | Peterborough - St Peter |
| Finney | A Gladstone | 1920 | M | Wesley |
| Finney | Gordon H | 1999 - 2010 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Fish | Charles | 1872 - 1873 | WM | Peterborough |
| Fisher | Albert | 1922 Aug 24> | SA | Norland |
| Fisher | Melville C (asst) | 1965 - 1971 | U | Peterborough - Trinity |
| Fitzgerald | R | 1953 Jun - 1954 Apr | RC | Peterborough - St Alphonsus |
| Fitzpatrick | Frank | <1982 - 1991 | RC | Hastings |
| Fitzpatrick | Hugh | 1846 - 1852 | RC | Douro |
| Fitzpatrick | Michael F | 1898 Jan - 1902 Jan 1 | RC | Youngs Point - St Mary |
| Fitzpatrick | Michael Francis | c1902 - 1916 Jan | RC | Ennismore |
| Flaherty | Clement | 1992 - 1993 | RC | Hastings |
| Flanagan | John | 1835 | WM | Cobourg |
| Fleetham | Thomas Harold | 1953 - 1957 | U | Bridgenorth |
| Fleming | John Malcolm (ret supply) | 1952 - 1954 | U | Kinmount |
| Fleming | Peter | 1882 Dec 14 - 1885 Apr 14 | P | Warsaw and Dummer |
| Fletcher | William George | 1929 | U | Westwood - St Andrews |
| Fletcher | William George | 1967 - 1969 | U | Havelock |
| Flowers | Robert T | 1997 - 2004 | A | Peterborough - St Alban |
| Floyd | Thomas Henry | 1939 - 1941 | A | Peterborough South |
| Floyd | Thomas Henry | 1981 - 1983 | A | Otonabee - St Mark |
| Floyd | Thomas Henry (asst) | 1946 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Floyd | Thomas Henry (asst) | 1970 - 1979 | A | Peterborough - St George |
| Floyd | Thomas Henry (Hon) (asst) | <1986 - 1987 | A | Otonabee - St Mark |
| Floyd | Thomas Henry (ret) | 1975 | A | Peterborough - St Alban |
| Foley | H W | 1897 | M | Harvey |
| Foley | Herbert W | 1902 - 1904 | M | South Dummer |
| Foley | Herbert W | 1907 - 1910 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Foley | Terrance | 1994 - date | RC | Bobcaygeon |
| Ford | Ken | 1991 | O | Peterborough Seventh Day |
| Forman | 1890 Oct | SA | Lakefield | |
| Foster | A H | 1897 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Foster | Alfred H | 1899 | M | Apsley |
| Foster | Ann E | 1998 - 2004 | U | Peterborough - St Andrews |
| Foster | Timothy M | 1984 - 1994 May> | PA | Havelock |
| Fotheringham | T F | 1875 Jul 21 - 1881 Aug 2 | P | Hastings Norwood |
| Fournier | John | 1988 - 1990 | O | Peterborough Seventh Day |
| Fowler | Robert | 1861 - 1862 | WM | Keene |
| Fox | D J | 1971 Sep 14 - 1974 | P | Peterborough - St Stephens |
| Fox | Thomas | 1875 | MC | Coboconk |
| Fox | Thomas | 1878 - 1880 | MC | Blairton |
| Fox | Thomas | 1881 - 1882 | MC | Warsaw |
| Frair | Harold E | <1920 Jul 17 - 1921 Jul 2> | M | Coe Hill |
| Francis | Ernest A | 1966 - 1973 | PA | Peterborough - Dublin St |
| Francis | Wayne E (asst) | <1971> | PA | Peterborough - Dublin St |
| Fraser | Donald | 1927 - 1929 | BF | Bobcaygeon |
| Fraser | J | 1889 | B | Bobcaygeon |
| Fraser | R McGregor | 1920 Mar - 1922 Nov | B | Gilmour Memorial |
| Frayne | D (asst) | 1968 - 1970 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Frazer | William | 1895 May 27> | SA | Peterborough |
| Freed | W | 1880 - 1881 | B | Bobcaygeon |
| Freed | William | 1891 - 1895 | B | Bobcaygeon |
| Freeston | Hugh Floyd | 1943 - 1944 | A | Apsley |
| Friedrich | C A | 1968 - 1974 | O | Peterborough - Ferndale |
| Friesen | J | 1981 | O | Peterborough Seventh Day |
| Frost | Harry A | 1907 - 1908 | M | South Dummer |
| Fulford | W H | 1894 | M | Harvey |
| Fullerton | John | 1958 - 1972 Aug | U | Keene |
| Furry | John | 1968 Jul 1 - 1971 Apr | B | Lakefield |
| Fusee | C Hiram | 1898 - 1900 | M | Warsaw |
| Fusee | Hiram | 1885 - 1887 | M | Kinmount |