| Name | Date | Location | ||
| Cachia | Edward | 1997 - 1998 | RC | Lakefield |
| Cafley | Ernest W | 1920 - 1921 | M | South Dummer |
| Calder | Alex J | 1961 Jan 12 - 1984 | P | Peterborough - St Paul |
| Caldwell | Paul | 2001 - 2002 | B | Woodview - Trinity |
| Cameron | J | 1859 - 1862 | B | Peterborough - Aylmer St |
| Cameron | J W | 1879 | BC | Ashburnham |
| Cameron | Malcolm & Faith | 1990 Jun - 1993 Aug> | SA | Peterborough South |
| Camp | A E | 1902 Sep 9 - 1906 | P | Havelock - Knox |
| Campbell | 1887 Jun 22 - 1887 Oct | SA | Lakefield | |
| Campbell | A | 1864 | ME | Hastings |
| Campbell | A G (student) | 1897 | B | Bobcaygeon |
| Campbell | A R | 1888 - 1890 | M | Hastings |
| Campbell | A R | 1894 - 1896 | M | Hastings |
| Campbell | Charles A | 1900 May 24 - 1905 | P | Lakefield and North Smith |
| Campbell | J Morrison | 1978 Sep 6 - 1979 | P | S Monaghan Fowlers Corners |
| Campbell | Peter | 1863 - 1864 | WM | Coboconk |
| Campbell | W A (supply) | 1942 - 1946 Jul | P | Keene Westwood |
| Campeau | Gerald | 2002 | RC | Norwood |
| Cannon | John | BC | Ashburnham | |
| Cantlon | David | 1856 - 1867 | BC | Peterborough |
| Caplan | Herman | 1905 - 1908 | A | Belmont |
| Capper | Joseph | 1900 Apr 19 - 1901 Apr | SA | Kinmount |
| Carbert | John R | 1990 | U | Peterborough - Northminster |
| Carlson | Lors W | 1956 - 1960 | U | Peterborough - George St |
| Carmichael | James | 1882 Oct 19 - 1893 | P | Norwood - St Andrews |
| Carpenter | Charles (asst) | 1911 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Carpenter | George | 1883 | MC | Bobcaygeon |
| Carr | George | <1842 Aug 27 - 1844 May 10> | WM | Asphodel |
| Carr | George | 1852 - 1853 | WM | Percy |
| Carr | George | <1854 Aug 12 - 1856 May 3> | WM | Norwood |
| Carr | Leslie | 1966 Jun 30 - 1967 Nov> | SA | Byersville |
| Carrey | 1889 Jan 31 - 1889 May | SA | Lakefield | |
| Carroll | Charles | 1872 - 1876 Sep | B | Peterborough - Aylmer St |
| Carroll | Cyril J | 1937 - 1956 Jun 1 | RC | Norwood |
| Carroll | John | 1829 | ME | Smith's Creek |
| Carroll | John | 1861 - 1863 | WM | Peterborough |
| Carruthers | Russell G | 1909 - 1910 | M | Cordova |
| Carruthers | William | 1895 Mar 21> | SA | Peterborough |
| Carson | Robert John | 1898 - 1901 | A | Belmont |
| Case | William | 1836 | WM | Rice Lake Indian |
| Casey | Daniel A | 1915 Jan - 1915 Mar 7 | RC | Norwood |
| Casey | Dominic J | 1889 - 1894 Jan | RC | Campbellford |
| Casey | Dominic J | 1894 Jan - 1901 | RC | Peterborough - St Peter |
| Casselman | Donald G | 1968 | B | Norwood |
| Casselman | Donald G | 1969 - 1970 | B | Campbellford |
| Caswell | James | 1844 - 1845 | MX | Cavan |
| Caswell | James | 1867 - 1870 | MX | Cavan |
| Cathcart | A B | 1941 - 1942 | A | Apsley |
| Cathcart | Joseph | 1942 Jul 10 - 1953 Jun 28 | P | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Cathcart | Robert Thompson | 1963 - 1968 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Catton | Donald | 1970 - 1972 | A | Stony Lake |
| Catton | Donald A | 1973 - 1977 | A | Peterborough - St Barnabas |
| Cayne | early | WM | Warsaw | |
| Chambers | G A | 1930 - 1943 | PA | Peterborough - Full Gospel |
| Chandler | J (student) | 1891 | B | Bobcaygeon |
| Chapman | Jas (student) | 1896 summer | B | Peterborough - Park St |
| Chapman | Jeremiah Anderson | 1880 - 1882 | MC | Campbellford |
| Chapman | Joseph F | 1919 - 1922 | M | Peterborough - St James |
| Chapple | J | 1864 | BC | Peterborough |
| Chase | P L | 1956 | FM | Cordova, Victoria, Havelock |
| Chatson | F Roy | 1929 - 1930 | FM | Peterborough |
| Chegahno | Anthony S | 1998 Apr - 2002 Oct> | PA | Curve Lake |
| Chiang | Jack | 1980 - 1982 Dec 7 | P | S Monaghan Fowlers Corners |
| Chivers | Charlotte | 1919 Jun 12> | SA | Peterborough 2 |
| Choi | Joseph | 2002 - date | RC | Peterborough - Korean M |
| Chorley | F L (student) | 1922 Jun - 1924 Sep | B | Indian River |
| Churchill | <1893 Nov> | SA | Norwood | |
| Churchill | J E | 1974 | PA | Peterborough - Full Gospel |
| Ciphery | Ernest | 1910 Jul 14> | SA | Kinmount |
| Clappison | Frederick Albert | 1972 - 1976 | U | Peterborough - Suburban |
| Clare | David R | 1905 | M | Wesley |
| Clare | David R | 1916 - 1918 | M | Warsaw |
| Clare | George R | 1887 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Clare | George R | 1894 - 1896 | M | Bridgenorth |
| Clark | Bill | 2001 - date | O | Pbo Christian Fellowship |
| Clark | Nathaniel | 1875 - 1885 Jan 15 | P | Lakefield and North Smith |
| Clark | Nathaniel | 1871 May 16 - 1875 Jun 15 | PF | Lakefield |
| Clarke | <1885 Jun 30> | O | Saved Army | |
| Clarke | A | 1866 | BC | Dummer - English Line |
| Clarke | Archibald | BC | Lakefield | |
| Clarke | Eric | 1925 Aug 2 - Dec> | SA | Haliburton |
| Clarke | Frank J | 1906 - 1907 | M | Cordova |
| Clarke | John S | 1888 - 1890 | M | Norwood |
| Clarke | R | 1888 Mar 1 - Apr | SA | Hastings |
| Clarke | Richard | 1874 - 1876 | MC | Norwood |
| Clarke | Thomas Benjamin | <1915 Apr - 1916 Jul 17> | A | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Clarke | Vera | 1951 Jun 28 - 1951 Oct> | SA | Campbellford |
| Clarke | W Herbert | 1905 | M | Blairton |
| Clarke | W Herbert | 1906 | M | Belmont |
| Clarry | J N | 1897 | M | Apsley |
| Clarry | John N | 1912 - 1914 | M | Peterborough - St James |
| Cleghorn | Thomas | 1846 | WM | Peterborough |
| Cleland | Albert S | <1932 Jul 5- 1938 Jun 29> | U | Norwood |
| Clemens | Mark | 1975 - 1976 | PA | Peterborough - Full Gospel |
| Clementi | Vincent | 1863 Oct - 1866 | A | Lakefield - Christ Church |
| Clementi | Vincent | 1866 - 1873 Sep | A | Lakefield - St John |
| Cleworth | Thomas | 1893 | M | Bridgenorth |
| Cleworth | Thomas | 1877 - 1878 | MC | Hastings |
| Clough | John Cyril | 1963 - 1974 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Cole | Nathaniel | 1948 - 1953 | U | Hastings |
| Coleman | William | 1843 | WM | Peterborough |
| Collins | G Victor | 1905 - 1907 | B | Lakefield |
| Collins | James S | 1956 - 1962 Sep | RC | Norwood |
| Collins | James S | 1962 - 1983> | RC | Peterborough - Sacred Heart |
| Collins | Joseph | 1942 - 1948 Apr | RC | Campbellford |
| Collins | Joseph | <1988 - 1996 | RC | Peterborough - Imm Concep |
| Collins | Joseph | 1997 - 2002 | RC | Ennismore |
| Colquahoun | Archibald | 1833 - 1843 Jan 11 | PK | Otonabee |
| Colquahoun | Archibald (missionary) | 1843 Jan 11 - 1853 | PK | Otonabee |
| Colquhoun | Archibald | 1852 | PF | Hastings |
| Colquhoun | Archibald (visitor) | ukn | PF | Westwood - St Andrews |
| Colwell | Edward Stuart | <1963 Oct 20-1965 May 22> | U | Coe Hill |
| Colwell | Edward Stuart | 1974 - 1978 | U | Hastings Roseneath |
| Colwell | G T | 1861 - 1863 | BC | Peterborough |
| Colwell | H J | 1859 | BC | Peterborough |
| Connell | John A | 1893 | M | Coe Hill |
| Connelly | M E | 1894 Jan - 1895 | RC | Campbellford |
| Connelly | Michael | 1895 Jul - 1897 Oct | RC | Hastings |
| Conners | F A | 1913 - 1914 | B | Peterborough - Park St |
| Connor | Kennedy W | 1971 Jun> | B | Lakefield |
| Connors | George W | 1900 - 1902 | B | Bobcaygeon |
| Constable (supply) | 1888 Jan 9 - 1888 Mar | SA | Lakefield | |
| Conway | Patrick | 1882 Dec 8 - 1887 fall | RC | Peterborough - St Peter |
| Conway | Patrick | 1888 Mar> | RC | Norwood |
| Conway | Russell | 1954 Dec - 1961 Aug | RC | Peterborough - St Alphonsus |
| Cook | D R (asst) | 1961 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Cook | Allen | 2000 | A | Bridgenorth Omemee |
| Cook | Allen | 1997 - 1999 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Cook | D R | 1962 - 1965 | A | Peterborough - All Saints |
| Cook | E | 1895 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Cook | E M | 1918 | M | Wesley |
| Cook | W H | 1902 | B | Havelock |
| Cook | William | 1876 - 1877 | MC | Coboconk |
| Cooke | Enoch B | 1899 - 1901 | M | South Dummer |
| Cooke | Ernest M | 1916 - 1917 | M | South Dummer |
| Cooke | J Mervin | 1976 - 1979 | FM | Peterborough |
| Cooley | C | 1887 Nov 24 - 1888 Feb | SA | Hastings |
| Coombs | Thomas | 1893 Apr 13 - 1893 Nov> | SA | Peterborough |
| Coon | Charles H | 1888 - 1889 | M | Lakefield |
| Coon | Charles H | 1893 - 1894 | M | Havelock |
| Coon | Charles H | 1905 - 1906 | M | Bobcaygeon |
| Coon | Charles H | 1907 - 1910 | M | Peterborough - Mark St |
| Coon | Charles H | 1911 - 1912 | M | Lakefield |
| Coone | J W | 1897 | M | Bridgenorth |
| Cooper | David G | 2007 - 2009 | P | Warkworth Hastings |
| Cooper | Glen (student) | 1973 | P | Warkworth Hastings |
| Cooper | James | 1953 Jul 2 - 1953 Nov> | SA | Fenelon Falls |
| Cooper | John Edmund | 1887 - 1890 | A | Hastings and Alnwick |
| Cooper | John Edmund | 1892 | A | Hastings and Alnwick |
| Copeland | G H | 1872 Jan 21 - 1873 Jun | BC | Ashburnham |
| Copeland | George H | <1912 Jul 24 - 1914 May 27> | M | Norwood |
| Coray | J W | 1928 - 1929 | FM | Cordova, Victoria, Havelock |
| Corbett | Donald J | 1962 - 1966 | B | Norwood |
| Corbett | Donald J | 1970 - 1978 | B | Gilmour Memorial |
| Cornish | David John (asst) | 1916 | A | Peterborough - St John |
| Cornish | T H (student) | 1899 - 1900 | B | Indian River |
| Cornish | William | 1899 Jan 19> | SA | Kinmount |
| Cornish | William | 1901 Apr 18 - Jul | SA | Kinmount |
| Corriveau | R | <1982 - 1983> | RC | Peterborough - St Alphonsus |
| Costello | Paul | 1921 - 1935 Nov | RC | Peterborough - St Peter |
| Costello | Paul | 1935 Nov - 1942 | RC | Hastings |
| Cotie | Grace | 1963 Jan 31 - 1963 Oct> | SA | Campbellford |
| Cottingham | E C (lay) | 1914 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Cotton | Henry | 1951 - 1959 | U | Peterborough - St Andrews |
| Couch | Isaac | 1910 - 1912 | M | Peterborough - George St |
| Coughlan | John F | 1969 Jun - 1977> | RC | Peterborough - Imm Concep |
| Coughlan | Timothy B | 1962 - 1970 Jun | RC | Peterborough - St Peter |
| Coughlan | Timothy B | 1975 Feb - 1980> | RC | Hastings |
| Coughlin | John | <1980 - 1988> | RC | Ennismore |
| Coughlin | L | <1980> | RC | Peterborough - Imm Concep |
| Coughlin | L | <1982 - 1983> | RC | Douro |
| Coughlin | Leo | 1998 - 2001 | RC | Peterborough - St Alphonsus |
| Coughlin | Leo T | 1971 Jun - 1977> | RC | Peterborough - St Anne |
| Courage | William Reeves | 1920 | A | Hastings and Roseneath |
| Courage | William Reeves | 1920 Dec - 1924 Jun | A | Peterborough South |
| Courtice | R T | 1869 | BC | Lakefield |
| Courtice | R T | 1894 | M | Seymour |
| Cox | Francis | <1985> | RC | Douro |
| Cox | Francis | <1990 - 1996 | RC | Peterborough - St Peter |
| Cox | L Francis | <1988> | RC | Peterborough - St Anne |
| Cox | Walter | 1923 Dec - 1926 Apr | A | Lakefield - St John |
| Cox | Wilbert Clarence | 1978 - 1999 | U | Peterborough - St James |
| Crabb | James A | 1974 Nov 28 - 1978 Sep 30 | P | Peterborough - St Giles |
| Cragg | Charles E | 1911 - 1913 | M | Peterborough - Mark St |
| Cragg | Edward | 1885 - 1892 | M | Hiawatha |
| Cragg | William Jay M | 1910 | M | Lakefield |
| Craig | J M | 1973 - 1974 | A | Kinmount Mission |
| Craig | Robert Brycelain | 1963 - 1966 | U | Peterborough - Trinity |
| Craig | William | 1871 | WM | Chandos |
| Craig | William | 1872 | WM | Bobcaygeon |
| Craig | William | 1873 | WM | Halls Bridge |
| Craig | William | 1873 | WM | Mud Lake Indian |
| Craigie | J R | 1884 - 1890 | P | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Craik | Frederick William | 1936 - 1950 | U | Peterborough - St James |
| Crate | Carl | 1961 Nov - 1968 | O | Peterborough - Ferndale |
| Craw | George I | 1914 - 1925 | P | Lakevale |
| Crawford | Kenneth James | 1952 - 1955 | U | Marmora |
| Crawford | Kenneth James | 1976 - 1981 | U | Coboconk |
| Cree | Matthew F | 1910 - 1912 | P | Norwood - St Andrews |
| Crego | Ruth | 1901 Apt 19> | SA | Peterborough |
| Creighton | Kennedy | 1839 - 1840 | MX | Peterborough |
| Creighton | Kennedy | 1840 | WM | Peterborough |
| Creighton | Walter John | <1890 Nov 11 - 1907 Jan 3> | A | Bobcaygeon and Dunsford |
| Creighton | Walter John | 1907 Feb - 1909 Nov | A | Lakefield - St John |
| Creighton | Walter John | 1927 Mar - 1938 | A | Lakefield - St John |
| Creswick | Walter | 1898 Sep - 1903 Jul | A | South Burleigh & Buckhorn |
| Croft | Evangeline | 1964 Jun 25 - 1965 Nov> | SA | Byersville |
| Crookshanks | Simon | 1908 - 1910 | M | Bridgenorth |
| Crookshanks | Simon | 1925 | M | Peterborough - George St |
| Cross | Raymond J | 1970 - 1977 Oct 9 | B | Peterborough - Edmison Hts |
| Crossley | D O | 1883 - 1884 | ME | Campbellford |
| Crossley | Daniel O | 1897 - 1901 | M | Peterborough - Charlotte St |
| Crothers | William J | 1904 - 1906 | M | Peterborough - George St |
| Crouter | D | 1863 | ME | Norwood |
| Crouter | Darius | 1893 | M | Harvey |
| Crowley | James | 1828 - 1833 | RC | Peterborough - St Peter |
| Crowther | William | 1906 Jul 19 - Sep> | SA | Kinmount |
| Cummer | Arthur Charles | 1906 - 1908 | A | Galway |
| Cunningham | C | 1911 - 1913 | FM | Peterborough |
| Cunningham | Thomas T | 2008 - 2011 | P | Peterborough - St Giles |
| Currie | Donald H | 1909 - 1914 | P | Lakevale |
| Currie | James | 1832 | ME | Cavan |
| Currie | Paul G | 2002 - 2006 | U | Peterborough - St James |
| Currie | Peter | 1907 - 1908 | P | Warsaw and Dummer |
| Curry | A | 1862 - 1863 | BC | Peterborough |
| Curtin | Paul | 1974 Aug 9 - 1980> | RC | Peterborough - St Alphonsus |
| Curtis | John | 1964 | B | Peterborough - Edmison Hts |
| Curts | James | 1891 - 1892 | M | Keene |